NEWSLETTER
203; FEBRUARY 1988 Edited
by: Liz Sagues
DIARY
An expanded list of HADAS events this time, to allow
diaries to be marked in advance of publication of the programme card -it will
appear, promises Dorothy Newbury, as soon as all dates are confirmed, and she
apologises for the delay.
Tuesday February 2 The Romans in Rumania, by Dr
Margaret Roxan
Dr Roxan, FSA, will be known to- many members who
attended her evening classes over the years --or -travelled--with—hex on
foreign visits. Her present position is Honorary Research Fellow in the
department of the Archaeology of the Roman Provinces at the Institute of
Archaeology and her particular interest is the Roman Army, especially the
auxiliary army of the Principate.
On her lecture subject, she provides the following
introductions A large part of the modern state of Rumania was annexed to form
the Roman province (later provinces) of Dacia in AD 106. Trajan's column in
Rome was erected to commemorate the conquest of Dacia by that military emperor;
its reliefs are justly world famous. Rumanian archaeologists are working very
hard to uncover the traces- of Trajan's wars of conquest, but they have also
discovered some fascinating remains of pre-Roman Dacia, as well as the traces
of Roman occupation which spanned the years AD 106-270. The talk will be'
accompanied by slides of these excavations in progress, as well as some of the
fascinating objects found in them, which are now in museums.
Tuesday
March 1 Tythe
Maps, by Geraldine Beech, Assistant Keeper, Map Department, Public Record Office.
Tuesday
April 5 Archaeology
and the Great Fire of London 1666, by Gustav Milne
Saturday
April 23 Morning
tour of St Lawrence Whitchurch, Edgware, by Sheila Woodward
Tuesday
May 10 Annual
General Meeting
Saturday
May 14 Outing
to .Windsor, led by Ted Sammes
SATURDAY
JUNE 11th Flag Fan,
Peterborough with Dr Francis Pryor
Saturday
July 16 Coach
tour of Docklands
September
(to
be confirmed) Derbyshire weekend, led by Peter Griffiths
Saturday
September 10 or 17 Charterhouse tour, led by Mary
0'Connell
Tuesday
October 4 Recent
Excavations at Waltham Abbey, by Peter Huggins
Saturday
October 8 Stepney
walk, led by Muriel Large
Tuesday
November 1 Excavations
at the Mint, by Peter Mills
Tuesday
January 3, 1989 Egypt in the Pyramid Era, by George
Hart
All lectures are at the Central Library, The
Burroughs, Hendon, 8pm for 8.30pm. Coffee is available, and a books selection.
ELEVEN
DECADES OF CONSERVATION; POLICY AND
PROBLEMS
Muriel Large reports on the January lecture
HADAS made a good start to 1988 with a talk by one
of its members, Philip Venning, who is Secretary of the Society for the
Protection of Ancient Buildings, on the work in which he is involved - work not
without its problems. One of these is how far "conservation" should
go: right back to the original building or accepting later but still historic
accretions? An example was the Norman building in which Oliver Cromwell went to
school, so restored in Victorian times that at first glance it appeared a
pastiche of itself.
Ruskin, Morris and Carlyle were all alarmed by the
worthy but misguided intentions of restorers of their time, and set up the
society in 1877 to pursue an enlightened policy - a policy continually under
review. Since 1877 the scope of conservation has spread so that now it covers
prehistoric and Roman sites and also 20th century buildings - such as the
Schreiber House, Hampstead, built in 1962 and regarded as a fine example of its
period, and the Electric Palace, the earliest cinema in Harwich. Mr Venning
stressed the importance of preserving the interior as well as the basic fabric
and regretted the stripping of the 18th-century interior of Fournier Street
mosque, in Spitalfields, originally a Huguenot chapel.
It could also be highly desirable to preserve a
group of buildings which were undistinguished individually but together formed
a significant and irreplaceable area. A manor house in Cornwall had one very
ordinary-looking wing until it was examined with a knowledgeable eye. It was
the oldest inhabited building in Great Britain, far older than the rest of the
house, and dated back to the time of the Conquest.
Even royal properties needed careful watching, a
floor of medieval tiles in part of the Tower of London having been recently at
risk, and so could be churches and chapels. Among religious bodies, only the
Anglican Church had its own assessment system overall and even .so the wishes
and means of a devoted but shrinking congregation could conflict with a wish to
preserve a historic and beautiful building which was falling into decay.
Conservation, we learned, could help destroy the
character of a building if the car parks and ticket offices needed to raise
funds were insensitively sited, and we were told of the anomaly of the Old
Curiosity Shop in Holborn, where commercialism had nevertheless helped to
preserve a genuine 16th century shop although its connection with Dickens was
tenuous. Caerphilly Castle was another instance, where some reconstruction had
taken place, but, done carefully and with expert knowledge, could arguably be
"said to have' enhanced its atmosphere and importance.
The training of young men in old crafts would seem
to be highly commendable when buildings were crying out for thatchers, for
example, but what if it led to a standardisation of styles so' that the East
Anglian method could appear where it had not been before; yes, it was keeping a
traditional roof on a cottage but at some cost to the final appearance if the
cottage was in Somerset.
Mr Venning's talk stimulated several questions, not
least on the sore point of what examples of present-day architecture would be
worth handing on to posterity, as well as the problems of over-visiting and
consequent erosion. One could only applaud the work of the SPAB and feel
relieved that one did not have to cope with its problems.
THE
EMPEROR'S TERRACOTTA WARRIORS
Sheila Woodward finds Eastern promise is realised
Few archaeological discoveries have fired the
imagination as powerfully as the uncovering of the array of terracotta warriors
guarding the tomb of the first Emperor of China. It has all the necessary
elements of excitement; the chance finding in 1974 of the first figures by
farmers digging a well, the gradual realisation of the size of the mausoleum
(over 7,000 figures to date, and digging continues) and the appreciation of the
exquisite workmanship of these sculpted terracotta life-size soldiers with
their horses and weapons.
We have all seen photographs and read accounts of
this wonderful site. Now for a few brief weeks (until February 20) we have an
opportunity to see some of these figures in London and a HADAS party visited
the exhibition at the Royal Horticultural Society's Old Hall, Vincent Square,
Westminster, on January 12.
There have been criticisms in the press of the small
size of the exhibition; only nine figures, two horses and a dozen or so
assorted exhibits such as weapons and weights. In fact, I found the limitation
in size an advantage. Each figure is so exquisitely detailed and so fascinating
that it repays long, slow study, and one had leisure to digest and appreciate
what one had seen.
The display is excellent and the recorded commentary
on the individual headsets provided was most helpful. There is an introductory
section, with pictures and maps, which sets the scene historically and
geographically and leads into the single hall in which all the figures are
displayed.
The Emperor Zheng in whose honour the figures were
made, seems to have been a most unpleasant character, and the potter-sculptors
who worked on the figures were slaves and convicts. Yet the overall impression
of the exhibition is of beauty and joy in craftsmanship. Each warrior-figure is
an individual, his face and expression quite distinctive. Every detail of
clothing is lovingly included: the rivets of the iron-mail coats, the tread on
the sole of a boot. The chariot-horse strains forward so that his shoulders
take the weight of the (now-vanished) chariot, his tail carefully tied up so
that, it cannot catch in the chariot wheels.
There is a reconstructed cross-bow, of which only
the bronze trigger mechanism remained, and batch of bronze bolts or arrowheads,
coated in chromium for durability and hardness. A bronze sword was similarly coated
and one realises how advanced technologically the Chinese Empire was in the
third century BC.
One cannot at this exhibition experience the majesty
and magnificence of the whole tomb complex of Emperor Zheng, with serried ranks
of terracotta warriors stretching over a vast area. Instead, one can begin to
appreciate and marvel at the artistic sensitivity and delicate technical skills
of the artisans of the Qin Empire. An exciting, enjoyable and most worthwhile
visit: thank you, Dorothy!
ARCHAEOLOGY
AND'THE ROOTS OF LANGUAGE Peter Pickering answers a HADAS
challenge
The November Newsletter suggested that someone might
write an appreciation for HADAS members of Professor Colin Renfrew's new book Archaeology and Language. Comparative
philology was a subject which fascinated me when I studied it - or rather the
ancient Greek dialects - 30 years ago, and I therefore ventured to take up
Christine Arnott's challenge.
The fact that requires explanation is that languages
with similarities - in grammar and/or vocabulary - which seem very unlikely to
be chance ones are spoken, or appear on inscriptions, in parts of the world as
distant as Ireland and Chinese Turkestan. The question is how and when this
came about.
The textbook I used - Buck's Comparative Grammar of
Greek and Latin - says; "What region was the common centre... has been a
notorious subject of discussion, with theories ranging from the Scandinavian Peninsula
to central Asia. No conclusive evidence is available or is likely to be
forthcoming. But" the best working hypothesis is that which favours the
region extending north of the Black Sea- and the Caucasus."
But the Cambridge Encyclopaedia of Language,
published last year, is much less uncertain (which is interesting, since it is
not in other respects traditionalist). It says: "Archaeological evidence
has shown the existence of a semi-nomadic population living in the steppe
regions of South Russia around 4000 BC, who began to spread into the Danube
area of Europe and beyond from around 3500 BC... The Celts emerged in south
central Europe around the fifth century BC, speaking common Celtic. In a series
of waves they spread throughout the rest of Europe."
It is the view set out in the Cambridge
encyclopaedia that Professor Renfrew challenges. His account of the various
Indo- European languages accords closely with what I learnt - there has been no
major new discovery since the (probable) decipherment of the Mycenaean Linear B
in the 1950s. Nor (though at one point he seems tempted to) does he dissent
from the basic tenet of comparative philology, that one language descends from
another and linguistic change is not random, but follows observable
regularities (as Latin "pater" is to English "father", so
is Latin "piscis" to English "fish").
He emphasises that languages are not totally
discrete entities, which split up or change suddenly into other totally
discrete ones (people did not speak Latin one year and Italian the next and,
despite education, Italian and French blur at the border). But this is not a
new point, and it is nonetheless true that there are languages just as there
are species of animals, defined by mutual intelligibility or interbreeding,
despite partial understanding between speakers of different languages and
hybridisation between different species.
What Professor Renfrew does not accept is that the
Indo-European languages were spread, through migrations or invasions, by people
identifiable with a particular physical type or using a particular type of
pottery or burial custom, from around the beginning of the Bronze Age.
He argues that they spread from Anatolia, with farming
itself, from the seventh millennium BC, by a slow expansion, as people set up
their own homes a few miles away from their parents' farms, into areas
inhabited previously by Mesolithic people. The languages of these Mesolithic
people may have been the ancestors of Basque, Etruscan and perhaps Pictish.
Professor Renfrew suggests that an Indo-European language, which developed in
Celtic, was spoken in Britain from before 4000 BC. In India also the Indus
Valley civilisation may have had an Indo-European language, and collapsed from
internal strains, not in the wake of an invasion of Aryans, as the traditional
view has it. Only Tocharian, isolated in Chinese Turkestan, may, Professor
Renfrew believes, have been carried by nomads.
I found Professor Renfrew's thesis attractive and
plausible and not perhaps as revolutionary as he seems to expect, I am not
competent to judge his archaeological arguments, though I do not like some
jargon words such as "processual" or the constant use of the word
"model" to denote what seems to me to be a good, old-fashioned
"theory". I am a little worried at finding the cradle of the Indo-
European languages in Eastern Anatolia, where the Hittite language was spoken,
since the greater part of that language's vocabulary is not Indo-European
(though its grammatical inflexions are); one would not naturally expect the
language remaining in the cradle area to be a deviant.
And one must not be too critical of those who have
believed in mass migrations or conquests as the mechanism that spread
Indo-European from Ireland to India, since we know how much such mechanisms
have spread Latin, Arabic, Turkish, Spanish and English, in their turn, across
vast tracts of the globe.
A
MEDIEVAL SURVIVAL
Deirdre Barrie makes a surprising discovery in the
City
It is truly astonishing to find such a large,
little-publicised and historic site in the City of London as the Charterhouse.
The Master's house is early Georgian, built on the 15th century entrance
gateway to the original monastery. Behind lies an imposing complex of buildings
including a splendid Tudor town house, parts of the original monastery
(including a recently-discovered monk's cell) and a Jacobean
school-cum-"hospital" or home for impoverished gentlemen or scholars.
Originally the gentlemen were "decrepit or old
Captaynes either at Sea or Land, Souldiers maymed or ympotent, decayed
Marchaunts, men fallen into decaye through Shipwrecke, Casualtie or Fyer or
such evill Accident, those that have been Captives under the Turkes etc."
The buildings of Sutton's Hospital are still home to more than 30 retired
gentlemen today.
The buildings
were the original site of Charterhouse School before it moved to Godalming in
1872. John Wesley, Baden-Powell and Thackeray were "Old Carthusians".
There is no space here to describe the fascinating
detail of the buildings, the chapel formed from the chapter house of the
monastery, the great hall with its impressive English renaissance screen, the
atmospheric rooms and interesting works of art.
It was here that Elizabeth I stayed for the first
five days of her reign, and from here she went out to her coronation. In the
very splendid Great Chamber with its Flemish tapestries, 16th century plaster
gilded ceiling and painted chimney-piece, James I created some 130 knights in
one afternoon. Sir Thomas More knew the earlier monastery well, and had had
thoughts of becoming a monk,
In 1535 the prior of the monastery was executed for
refusing to acknowledge Henry VIII as head of the Church. One of his arms was
fastened above the gate as a dire warning to the monks. It is said that
hundreds of years later earnest schoolboys peered up at the archway, hoping to
perceive the nail-hole.
HADAS members will have the opportunity to see the
Charterhouse in September, under the guidance of Mary O'Connell. See Diary for
preliminary information; full details later.
A
HAPPY CHRISTMAS
A message of thanks from George Ingram
I read with much interest the report by Marjorie
Errington on the visit to the Museum of London on December 9 when Dr Francis
Sheppard gave a talk on the history of the two museums which were united in
1975.
This was followed by an enjoyable repast at The
Crowders Well - I was very sorry I could not attend on this occasion, but a few
days later I was delighted to receive from the postman (and Ted Sammes), a
large envelope which contained a menu card on which many members of the party
had written little messages,. May I take this opportunity to express my very
grateful thanks to all concerned for this unique memento, which brought to mind
many happy times spent together, in our common interests in archaeology and
local history. May the society continue to flourish!
RAILWAY
REMAINS
John Crowther describes a lost line and modern plans
for it
There are still clues to the railway that used to
run from Mill Hill East to Edgware, in spite of modern building and the coming
of the Ml.
A short stretch of the railway's line, between Deans
Lane, Burnt Oak, and Mill Hill Broadway Station, is going to be made, jointly
by the London Borough of Barnet and the London Wildlife Trust, into a nature
reserve. What, I wonder, is going to happen to the rest of the land, much of
which is simply lying waste at present, but can easily be seen on a road map.
Some has been built on, some is being used as allotments, some is going to
extend Lyndhurst Park, but all that leaves some promising land which might someday
provide an extension of the nature reserve habitats.
There had been a proposal by Barnet to open a
walkway along the land. This fell through. Then the GLC described it as "a
site of borough importance" and said that "although sites of a
similar quality may be found elsewhere in London, damage to a site of borough importance would imply a significant
loss to that borough". But you know what happened to the GLC... Still
there is no public access.
Actually, it could be this very privacy which makes
it interesting to the wildlife enthusiasts - a wide variety of plants and
animals is already on the site, which is claimed to be- a valuable wildlife
refuge within a suburban area. The archaeological and educational interests
still have to be put there.
It is a "suburban" area because it is
hemmed in by roads, offices, houses, railways and the Ml. "Suburban"
also points to the big snag - refuse tipping. Brick rubble is all right, it is
good for insects and the like- all other litter needs to be removed as a high
priority. This one-off operation would let the site recover quickly and local
residents will be asked to enjoy the site, not to deface it.
As for archaeology, already there is a blind subway
in Deans Lane, a bridge over nothing at Lyndhurst Park, a line of poplars in
Langley Park and the shapes of residential streets all over the place. All are
good clues - the railway is by no means dead.
THE
BEGINNINGS OF AGRICULTURE; UNANSWERED QUESTIONS
Professor David Harris, professor of Human
Environment at the Institute of Archaeology, posed some of them on January 21,
when he launched the University of London Extra-Mural Department's new Thursday
lecture series, Stock and Crop; Aspects of Early Domestication.
Inquiry into agriculture's beginnings, he said, went
back to classical Greek times, perhaps even earlier, he said, and most recently
centred on two theories, the "revolutionary" - that it all happened quickly,
in a limited number of centres and diffused out from them - and the
"gradualist" - that it arose in fits and starts, most likely in many
different places at many different times. Gradualism was now most in favour,
but the case remained far from proved. Hoped-for precision from radio-carbon
dating had not been realised, though the new accelerator mass spectrometer
technique was finally providing dates for actual fragments of plant and animal
bone remains.
He looked at the evidence that could be gathered
from people still living primitive lifestyles and from the most important of
current sites - notably Tell Abu Hureyra in Syria. "The earlier idea that
agriculture was in some way an inevitable process has been reversed," he
argued. "The problem now is not why did it not happen earlier, but why did
it happen at all. Why are we not all hunter gatherers, because it is so much
easier a life?"
The challenge now facing archaeologists was to
devise the right questions to ask of the archaeological remains, to turn
theories into fact.
Other lecturers in the series include Tony Legge
(February 4) and Warwick Bray (February ll), while the subjects span the world,
taking in India, the Andes and Africa as well as Europe and the Near East.
Lectures are each Thursday until March 10, at the Institute of Archaeology,
Gordon Square, Bloomsbury, at 7pm, price £2.50 a time.
COPPER-BOTTOMED
ISLAND
The wealth of Cyprus in antiquity was built on
copper, and there's no mistaking the importance of the mineral in the new A.G.
Leventis Gallery of Cypriot Antiquities, - latest of the British Museum's Greek
and Roman galleries to be refurbished, The display is entirely new, though some
of the individual objects have been seen before, and it is arranged
thematically rather than by period. Such an arrangement, argues Veronica
Tatton-Brown, the BM Cypriot specialist responsible, makes the occasional gap
in the chronological sequence less obvious and, more importantly, it presents
Cyprus's past in a way that should be more appealing to visitors.
And there is much that appeals, the larger objects
free of inhibiting glass cases, the smaller ones well displayed. Themes range
from flora and fauna to weapons and warfare, taking in others' such as trade
arid manufacture, writing and the human form en route, all covering the period
4?500BC to 330AD. The gallery is a permanent one, and should be open normal
museum hours.